Ever get that spine-tingling chill while losing yourself in a book? Supernatural thriller and mystery books in particular are chosen because they could make people scared while reading and at the same time hardly let them let go of the book. These books combine the element of mystery with spades of suspense, aimed at readers who love their adrenalin rush mixed with the paranormal.
So, as the year 2025 starts, let me gather 13 best supernatural thriller and mystery books that you are definitely going to love. Whether you are a fan of hair-raising paranormal thrillers or historical supernatural mysteries, this list has something for everyone.
Why Readers Love Supernatural Thrillers
Have you ever been pulled into a story that takes you far beyond ordinary moments of daily life? Supernatural thrillers are those wild rides that combine mysterious scenes with intense tension. They’re the kind of books that have you on the edge of your seat, just when you think, “Aha, I’ve got this!”—bam! A paranormal element or a ghostly surprise turns everything upside down.
End Your Search Here: The List of Best Supernatural Books of 2025
1. Leaf Runner by John C. Stroebel
Each morning, Mercer Evans awakens from a nightmare in which he is about to die but soon discovers it is not he who is facing death. When he uncovers a link to his family’s hidden past, he falls into a world of time travel and joins a group known as the Leaf Runners, who’re in charge of protecting history from the others who are using their time travel abilities to alter it.
Mercer realizes his dreams are like flashing red lights, hinting at his part in this mystical showdown. Racing against zealots bent on altering pivotal historical events, he faces tough choices about morality and the dangers of changing the past. With the future of the world at stake, Mercer must confront his fears and embrace his unexpected role.
Leaf Runner is one of the best supernatural thriller books of 2025, offering suspense, history, and a gripping supernatural mystery.
2. Honeysuckle and Bone by Trisha Tobias
Teenager Carina Marshalls move to Jamaica is meant to be the chance for a new start to make new friends and leave her past behind her. But her new job as a nanny for the Hall family at the Blackbead House, an old house that one can imagine was built with spirits in mind, turns out to be a gruesome experience.
Strange whispers echo through the halls, doors creak open on their own, and shadows flicker where no one stands. As Carina tries to make sense of the unexplainable occurrences, she befriends Aaron, a local who warns her that the house’s dark history has claimed lives before.
Atmospheric, suspenseful, and spine-chilling, this story is a perfect pick for fans of paranormal thriller books who love edge-of-your-seat mysteries.
3. The Macabre by Kosoko Jackson
Artist Lewis Dixon thought his family’s legacy ended with his great-grandfather’s death, but when he inherits a collection of eerie, life-like paintings, he realizes the truth is far darker. Each painting holds supernatural power and is tied to a series of tragic deaths spanning generations.
Determined to break the curse, Lewis sets out on a dangerous journey to destroy the paintings, uncovering an ancient and sinister force behind their creation. As he unravels their secrets, Lewis faces chilling visions, encounters hostile spirits, and discovers his own connection to the curse.
This gripping story of family, legacy, and the supernatural is an unforgettable addition to the list of supernatural thriller books for 2025, blending action, suspense, and vivid storytelling that will leave readers breathless.
4. A Sea of Unspoken Things by Adrienne Young
When James Golden returns to Six Rivers, California, to settle his twin brother Johnny’s affairs, he finds more than just paperwork waiting for him. As he sorts through Johnny’s belongings, James stumbles upon cryptic notes and unsettling artifacts that suggest his brother was involved in something sinister.
The deeper he digs, the more he uncovers layers of hidden family trauma and dark secrets that threaten to pull him under. With every revelation, James is forced to confront his own past and the shadowy forces that may have led to Johnny’s death.
This historical supernatural thriller is packed with gripping suspense and a haunting atmosphere, keeping readers hooked until the final, chilling twist.
5. Beautiful Ugly by Alice Feeney
After a devastating loss, Grady retreats to a remote Scottish island, only to meet a woman who bears an uncanny resemblance to his missing wife. As he digs deeper, supernatural twists blur the lines between reality and illusion, forcing him to question everything he thought he knew. A perfect choice for readers who love supernatural mystery books that explore themes of identity and loss.
6. Cross My Heart by Megan Collins
Rosie Lachlan’s obsession with Morgan Thorne takes a sinister turn when she begins to uncover dark truths about her own heart transplant. As her memories intertwine with a stranger’s life, Rosie realizes that her new heart may hold the key to uncovering a deadly secret.
This paranormal thriller book offers an unforgettable mix of suspense and mystery.
7. The Crash by Freida McFadden
Caught in a deadly snowstorm, pregnant Tegan finds herself stranded in a cabin with strangers harboring dark secrets. What begins as a safe haven soon turns into a terrifying nightmare as the truth about her hosts comes to light. As eerie occurrences unfold and hidden agendas are revealed, Tegan must fight to protect herself and her unborn child.
This action-packed story combines the best elements of supernatural thriller books and suspense, keeping readers hooked until the shocking finale.
8. Close Your Eyes and Count to 10 by Lisa Unger
When contestants of a high-stakes hide-and-seek game start disappearing, influencer Maverick Dillan’s island retreat becomes a death trap. As a violent storm isolates them from the mainland, tensions rise and alliances crumble. With danger lurking at every corner and the lines between players and predators blurring, survival becomes a game of wit and instinct. This suspense thriller book offers high-stakes tension with a supernatural edge, making it a gripping, edge-of-your-seat read.
9. The Buffalo Hunter Hunter by Stephen Graham Jones
In this historical supernatural thriller, a Blackfeet vampire seeks justice for his tribe’s tragic past, haunted by the loss of 217 members to betrayal and violence. Set in the early 1900s, the story is narrated through confessional visits, exploring themes of revenge, identity, and the supernatural. As the vampire’s path collides with mortal and immortal enemies, the novel delivers an evocative and haunting tale that lingers long after the final page.
10. The Inheritance by Trisha Sakhlecha
A luxurious private island becomes the backdrop for betrayal, greed, and murder as the Agarwal family fights over their patriarch’s fortune. Beneath the surface of opulent dinners and family gatherings lie simmering resentments and long-buried secrets. As the tension escalates and one of them is found dead, the family is forced to confront the eerie forces at play. This gripping novel combines family drama with a touch of the supernatural, making it one of the best supernatural thriller books of the year.
11. Killer Potential by Hannah Deitch
Accused of murder, SAT tutor Evie must unravel a dark conspiracy to clear her name. Fleeing across the country, she uncovers a series of cryptic clues linking her to a mysterious organization with a sinister agenda. As she pieces together the truth, she finds herself entangled in a supernatural mystery that challenges her understanding of reality. This supernatural mystery book combines thrilling action and clever twists, making it a must-read for fans of paranormal thrillers.
12. A Thousand Natural Shocks by Omar Hussain
Reporter named Dash investigates a cult that sells a pill that can wipe out a certain painful day from someone’s memory: however, there are some nasty consequences. The ever-deepening exploration of cult secrets leads to Dash’s memory loss which makes it uncertain what is real and what is actually manipulation on the part of cult members. When his time ticks away and his defenselessness increases, he breaks the secret to reveal the cult’s plan before it is too late. While the plot has supernatural motives blended with the thriller, the psychological aspect of the story serves as suspense with a pinch of intellectual angle.
13. King of Ashes by S.A. Crosby
In a small Southern town, a detective’s investigation into arson reveals buried secrets and racial tensions. Each fire uncovers new evidence pointing to a decades-old conspiracy tied to a local legend of a vengeful ghost. As the detective digs deeper, he must confront his own past while battling forces determined to keep the truth hidden. This intense story blends social commentary with supernatural thriller books, making it a standout for 2025.
Final Thoughts
From haunted forests to cursed artifacts, these supernatural thriller books and supernatural mystery books offer an unforgettable mix of suspense, action, and eerie twists. Whether you prefer historical settings or modern-day suspense, there’s a story here for everyone.
Which of these best supernatural books of 2025 will you pick up next?
